⚽ Breaking

Man City 115 charges: Maresca’s perfect start and the points deduction that could undo it

Roy Keane was asked on Sky Sports on Sunday what it would mean if Manchester City were ten points clear…

Roy Keane was asked on Sky Sports on Sunday what it would mean if Manchester City were ten points clear at Christmas, and his reply was “Let’s hope they get beaten.” The studio didn’t quite know what to do with it. Keane may have been half joking, but he had put his finger on the strangest thing about this Premier League season: City are top after six straight wins, with the 115 charges verdict still under appeal, and nobody, the club included, can yet say what those points are worth.

Manchester City’s perfect start under Maresca

Judged purely as football, the start has been hard to fault. Enzo Maresca took over a squad in transition when Pep Guardiola stepped down in the summer, and the Opta supercomputer gave City a 19.6% chance of the title before a ball was kicked. Six games later they have 18 points and a three-point lead over Arsenal. Maresca has also joined Guardiola, Carlo Ancelotti, and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as the only managers to win their first six league games in charge of a Premier League club.

Anfield was the most convincing of those wins, even if it took a while. Liverpool had the better of a first half played in front of relentless booing. City were still waiting for a way in when Ryan Gravenberch was sent off for a second booking on 62 minutes, after a foul on Jeremy Doku. Erling Haaland scored three minutes later, when Doku’s shot deflected off Alexis Mac Allister into his path. Doku then curled in the second himself, and Rayan Cherki finished off a move that Josko Gvardiol opened with a cheeky flick.

That gave City consecutive league wins at Anfield for the first time since January 1953, and Andoni Iraola his first defeat as Liverpool’s head coach. The red card matters when judging the margin. So does the fact that City’s 1–0 win at Old Trafford in September came from a Haaland goal that Pro Ref has since admitted should not have been given. Still, a team that has put four past Crystal Palace and five past Sunderland and has now won comfortably on Merseyside is not top by accident.

Man City under Maresca · 2026/27
Premier League · six games · six wins
18
Points from 18
3
Points clear of Arsenal
Bournemouth (H)Won
Crystal Palace (A)4–1
Coventry (H)1–0
Manchester United (A)Pro Ref error1–0
Sunderland (H)5–3
Liverpool (A)3–0
Opta pre-season title chance19.6%
ⓘ Fourth manager to do it. Maresca joins Guardiola (City, 2016), Ancelotti (Chelsea, 2009) and Solskjaer (Manchester United, 2018/19) as the only managers to win their first six Premier League games in charge of a club.

The verdict on the 115 charges and City’s appeal

The independent commission found City guilty of 114 of the 115 charges brought in February 2023. The charges covered nine seasons from 2009 to 2018, plus years of failing to cooperate with the league’s investigation. The central finding was that City disguised more than £830m of illicit funding. That money let them outspend their rivals by almost double in net terms over the period. Richard Masters has described it as the most significant disciplinary case in the league’s history.

City deny all of it. The club lodged what it called a comprehensive appeal at 7pm on Thursday 1 October, a day inside the deadline, arguing that the commission made material errors of law, principle, and fact. Under the league’s rules, a new three-member appeal board should hold its hearing within 12 weeks and rule within 30 days of that hearing finishing. That puts the hearing around Christmas and a ruling into January at the earliest. The sanction has not been set at all. It will be decided at a separate, confidential hearing before the commission, and City can appeal that as well.

The 115 charges · where the case stands
Premier League v Manchester City · as of 13 October 2026
Charges issuedFebruary 2023
Commission hearingSept–Dec 2024
Guilty finding114 of 115 charges
Illicit funding disguised£830m+
Appeal lodgedDone1 Oct · 7pm
Appeal hearing duePendingby ~24 Dec
Appeal ruling30 days after hearing
SanctionTBCNot yet set
Sanctions available to the commission
Reprimand Fine Suspension Points deduction Expulsion
Only precedent: Everton, 202310 pts, cut to 6
ⓘ Two hearings, not one. The appeal board rules on the guilty finding. The punishment is set separately, in a confidential hearing before the commission, and City can appeal that too.

We’ll be following the appeal and every result in between in our Manchester City news and analysis, with the rest of the title race covered in our latest Premier League coverage.

What a points deduction could do to the title race

The punishments available run from a reprimand or a fine through to a points deduction or expulsion from the league. The only recent precedent is Everton, who were docked ten points in 2023 for breaching the spending rules over a single three-year period. That deduction was reduced to six on appeal. City have been found guilty of something far larger and far longer, so Everton’s figure is close to useless as a guide to what is coming.

Some people argue the financial rules were built to protect an established elite, and Gary Neville has long held a version of that view. Even so, he told Sky on Sunday that he would happily be taken off City games until the appeal is heard. The argument against the rules falls down on one point. The commission did not punish City for spending too much. It found that they hid where the money came from, which is a question of honesty rather than economics.

All of this makes the table an uncomfortable thing to read. Liverpool have lost three points they will never get back, whatever happens to City later. Arsenal are chasing a leader whose total could be halved or erased. The Anfield crowd chanted that City were going down as the players left the pitch, and as mockery it had more substance than usual, because expulsion is on the published list of outcomes.

Manchester City’s fixtures before the Arsenal trip

The next six weeks are worth watching precisely because they look so quiet. Anfield is likely to be the most hostile ground City visit all season, and they have already been to Old Trafford. Five of their next six games are at home, starting with Paris Saint-Germain in the Champions League on Wednesday and Ipswich on Saturday. Villa Park on 24 October is their only away league game this month. After that come Brighton at home, Nottingham Forest away, and Fulham at home, before the trip to Arsenal on 28 November.

On this form City could arrive at the Emirates with a lead well beyond three points, at roughly the moment the 12-week window for the appeal hearing closes. Jamie Carragher said on the same programme that the case has to be resolved before the season ends. He is right. A title decided in a hearing room in June would do the league more lasting damage than any sanction could do to City.

The appeal could also reduce the number of proven charges, and a smaller case would mean a smaller punishment. That is clearly the outcome City are playing for. The rules also allow the appeal board to send the case back to the commission rather than rule on it. If that happens, the clock starts again, and nobody has yet explained what a title race looks like with a fresh hearing scheduled for March.

more articles

England squad for Croatia and Spain: Jobe Bellingham in, Palmer, Saka and Foden out

There will be two Bellinghams in the England...

Barcelona 3–0 Aston Villa: Raphinha double and Yamal’s record goal end Villa’s perfect start

Aston Villa arrived at the Camp Nou with...

Man Utd 3–2 Roma: Cunha buys Carrick time, but the first half still needs explaining

At half-time at Old Trafford on Tuesday night,...

In This Article

Hot Topics

Browse Topics

Premier League
Transfer News
Arsenal
Liverpool
Chelsea
Man City
Man United
Champions League
Tottenham
Newcastle
Aston Villa
La Liga
Bundesliga
Serie A
Features
World Cup