⚽ Breaking

Carrick’s days are numbered as Man Utd draw up a five-man shortlist

Michael Carrick is still Manchester United’s manager, and he will be on the touchline when Bournemouth come to Old Trafford…

Michael Carrick is still Manchester United’s manager, and he will be on the touchline when Bournemouth come to Old Trafford on Sunday. Beyond that game, Sky Sports says the club has made no decision at all. That would be more reassuring if the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler had not reported on Thursday that a list of possible successors already exists, with Eddie Howe, Kieran McKenna, Antonio Conte, Fabian Hürzeler, and Julian Nagelsmann on it.

The Como defeat that turned concern into a plan

Wednesday night in Italy was when unease about Carrick’s position became something closer to a succession plan. Cesc Fàbregas’s Como won 4–1 in the Champions League. Nico Paz scored twice and Anastasios Douvikas and Jacobo Ramón added the others. Joshua Zirkzee’s stoppage-time goal came far too late to change the mood. Como scored after 118 seconds, a week after Atlético Madrid had needed only 47, which made United the first English team to concede inside the opening two minutes of back-to-back major European matches.

How completely Como controlled the game did as much damage as the scoreline. They kept the ball for long spells and finished with 594 completed passes, a total no side had reached against United in this competition since Barcelona in April 2019. Carrick did not pretend otherwise. He called the performance unacceptable and went over to apologise to the away end at full time.

The wider picture is worse. United have now gone seven games without a win in all competitions, their longest run since December 2015, when it stretched to eight. That leaves them with two victories from ten matches all season. Seven league games have brought seven points. Ipswich, beaten 5–2 at Old Trafford in August, are still the only side United have beaten in the league, and the four draws and the derby defeat since then show how far a team that finished third last season has fallen. Add a League Cup exit at Brighton and you arrive at the club’s worst start to a top-flight season in 40 years.

Carrick: then vs now
The 2025/26 interim spell against the 2026/27 start
71
Points · 2025/26 final total
7
Points · after seven games of 2026/27
2025/26 · Interim
Took over in January6th
First two gamesW City · W Arsenal
Final position3rd
RewardPermanent job, May
2026/27 · Permanent
Premier League recordW1 D4 L2
All competitions2 wins in 10
Current run7 without a win
League CupOut v Brighton
Champions League3 pts from 3 games
ⓘ Worst start to a top-flight season in 40 years. The 4–1 defeat at Como made this United’s longest winless run since an eight-game streak in December 2015.
Only league win of 2026/27: 5–2 v Ipswich, August · 71 points is United’s full 2025/26 total · Next: Man Utd vs Bournemouth · 25 October 2026 · Old Trafford · 2pm · Sky Sports

Bruno Fernandes breaks ranks with Carrick

Carrick could probably have ridden out the results for a while longer. Doing it while his captain explains the defeats on television is a different problem. Bruno Fernandes played as a false nine and was substituted after 67 minutes. He told TNT Sports that the decision not to press man-to-man had come from the staff. Asked whether Carrick had got the tactics wrong, he said that was for the manager and his staff to judge, not him, and added that sometimes “you have to be more brave under pressure.”

Carrick did not let it pass. In his press conference he disputed his captain’s account and said that whatever system a team plays, if players do not run forward and back, “you ain’t going to win.” Sky Sports News reports that Fernandes will keep the armband and is unlikely to be disciplined. That says a good deal about where the balance of power sits at Carrington. It also came only a week after Lisandro Martínez publicly criticised technical director Jason Wilcox, so this is the second senior player in a fortnight to question the club’s direction in public.

Who is on Man Utd’s five-man shortlist

Four of the five names are out of work. That is the most revealing detail in the report, because United could appoint any of them without paying compensation, and the list looks built for speed.

Howe left Newcastle in the summer on the eve of the Premier League season. He also has history with this vacancy: he was reportedly put forward by Dan Ashworth, then United’s director of football, before the club appointed Ruben Amorim. Conte has been without a club since leaving Napoli, although reports suggest some people at Old Trafford have reservations about him. McKenna, once one of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s assistants at United, left Ipswich in the summer after taking them back to the Premier League. Nagelsmann has been available since July, when he left the Germany job after a penalty shootout defeat to Paraguay in the World Cup round of 32.

Hürzeler is the exception. He has admirers at Old Trafford, but talkSPORT reports that the Brighton manager is not interested, and prising him away from the south coast would mean a substantial compensation fee. Not every outlet has the same names. A separate report carried by Football365 puts Aston Villa’s Unai Emery at the top of a six-man list. talkSPORT, though, says Emery, who was part of United’s process before Carrick was given the job permanently, would need convincing to leave Villa.

Man Utd’s five-man shortlist
Who could replace Carrick, and what each would cost to appoint
Eddie Howe
Left Newcastle in the summer · no compensation
Our pick
Julian Nagelsmann
Left Germany in July · no compensation
Available
Kieran McKenna
Left Ipswich after promotion · former United coach
Available
Antonio Conte
Left Napoli · reservations reported inside the club
Available
Fabian Hürzeler
Brighton manager · compensation required
Not interested
ⓘ Four of the five are free agents. Only Hürzeler would cost a fee, and talkSPORT reports he does not want the job. A separate Football365 report puts Unai Emery top of a six-man list.
Shortlist: Daily Mail (Chris Wheeler) · Hürzeler stance: talkSPORT · Next: Man Utd vs Bournemouth · 25 October 2026 · Old Trafford · 2pm · Sky Sports

Why Howe makes more sense than Conte or McKenna

Put the five names side by side and they describe several different football clubs. Conte would bring immediate intensity and a Premier League title on his record. United, though, have been chasing that kind of jolt for years, and anyone who remembers how his time at Tottenham finished in 2023 will struggle to picture him building something patient. McKenna appeals for almost the opposite reason: he spent years on the coaching staff under Solskjaer, and supporters trust that he understands the place. Appointing a former insider who has never managed at this level would repeat the gamble United took on Carrick, with less evidence behind it.

Nagelsmann is the most interesting name and probably the riskiest. He has never managed in England, and he would arrive straight off a World Cup exit that cost him the Germany job. Howe is the least exciting of the five and the most sensible. He took Bournemouth into the Premier League, won the Carabao Cup with Newcastle in 2025, and is available now without a fee. If United want someone who will still be in the job in three years, he is where the conversation should start.

Bournemouth at Old Trafford is Carrick’s last argument

None of this erases what Carrick did last season. When he arrived in January, United were sixth, and his first two games brought wins over Manchester City and Arsenal. By May they had finished third on 71 points, which turned an interim arrangement into a permanent contract. Fifteen league matches in charge were enough to put him on the shortlist for the Premier League’s Manager of the Season award. That record explains why the club has hesitated, and it is also why this collapse has been so hard to explain.

Bournemouth come to Old Trafford on Sunday at 2pm, live on Sky Sports. Benjamin Šeško is injured, while Martínez and Ayden Heaven could return. A win would not solve Carrick’s problems, but a defeat would make the shortlist the only subject at the club next week. A list that puts Conte and McKenna side by side suggests the club has not settled what kind of team it wants to be, and it is not clear that Wilcox and the people above him have worked that out either.

Man Utd next manager: frequently asked questions

Has Michael Carrick been sacked by Manchester United?

No. As of Friday 23 October, Carrick is still Manchester United’s manager, and Sky Sports reports he will take charge of Sunday’s game against Bournemouth. The club has made no decision about his future beyond that match.

Who is on Man Utd’s shortlist to replace Carrick?

According to the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler, United’s five-man shortlist is Eddie Howe, Kieran McKenna, Antonio Conte, Fabian Hürzeler, and Julian Nagelsmann. A separate report carried by Football365 has Aston Villa’s Unai Emery at the top of a six-man list, but talkSPORT says Emery would need convincing to leave Villa.

Why is Carrick under pressure at Old Trafford?

The 4–1 defeat at Como in the Champions League left United seven games without a win in all competitions, their longest run since December 2015. They have won two of their ten matches this season and taken seven points from seven league games, with a League Cup exit at Brighton on top. It is the club’s worst start to a top-flight season in 40 years.

What did Bruno Fernandes say about Carrick’s tactics?

After the Como defeat, Fernandes told TNT Sports that the decision not to press man-to-man had come from the coaching staff. When asked whether Carrick had got the tactics wrong, he said that was for the manager and staff to judge. Carrick replied that whatever system a team plays, players who do not run will not win. Sky Sports News reports that Fernandes will keep the captaincy.

Would Man Utd have to pay compensation to appoint a new manager?

For four of the five names, no. Howe, Conte, McKenna, and Nagelsmann are all out of work after leaving Newcastle, Napoli, Ipswich, and Germany respectively. Hürzeler is the exception: Brighton would expect a substantial compensation fee, and talkSPORT reports he is not interested in the job anyway.

When did Carrick become Man Utd’s permanent manager?

Carrick took over as interim manager in January with United sixth in the Premier League. He won his first two games against Manchester City and Arsenal and finished the season third on 71 points. That run earned him the permanent job in May.

When is Man Utd’s next match?

United host Bournemouth at Old Trafford on Sunday 25 October, with kick-off at 2pm, live on Sky Sports. Benjamin Šeško is injured, while Lisandro Martínez and Ayden Heaven could return.

more articles

England squad for Croatia and Spain: Jobe Bellingham in, Palmer, Saka and Foden out

There will be two Bellinghams in the England...

Barcelona 3–0 Aston Villa: Raphinha double and Yamal’s record goal end Villa’s perfect start

Aston Villa arrived at the Camp Nou with...

Man Utd 3–2 Roma: Cunha buys Carrick time, but the first half still needs explaining

At half-time at Old Trafford on Tuesday night,...

In This Article

Hot Topics

Browse Topics

Premier League
Transfer News
Arsenal
Liverpool
Chelsea
Man City
Man United
Champions League
Tottenham
Newcastle
Aston Villa
La Liga
Bundesliga
Serie A
Features
World Cup